A TV commercial for “The Steve Harvey Show” flashed between the traffic and weather reports while I was getting dressed. The upcoming episode was focused on dating advice for singles, because if anyone is qualified to offer dating advice, it’s a self-proclaimed God-fearing (and admittedly adulterous) comedian on his third marriage in equally as many decades. Step aside, Dr. Phil. There’s a new love doc in Tinseltown. Perhaps if you’re a connoisseur of the written word, you have come to rely on the relationship advice of Cosmopolitan, or one of a dozen other self-hating magazines sandwiched between packs of Cool Mint Trident and great literary works like The National Enquirer. If these peer-revered psychology experts can dole out dating advice at a third-grade level, I figure I am almost as qualified to comment. Almost.
It’s Friday night. Ladies, you’re primped and prepped. Locks are perfect, makeup is flawless. Gentlemen, your hair is combed, your back is waxed. Your makeup is…hopefully nonexistent. (But we won’t judge.) You are officially date ready.
Wait, “date” ready? Is this a date? Did anyone use the word “date?” Is it just dinner? Are we just hanging out??Could I have spent that waxing money on booze instead??? SHIT!
Just breathe. Let’s see how it goes.
Okay, this is going well. Let’s get the check and see who reaches for it. Yeah! That will decide it. The check is patiently perched on the table like an unsuspecting gazelle at the watering hole. Any minute now. Wait for it. Wait…for…it.
Uh oh, no one is reaching. It’s a standoff. Well, this is awkward.
While grabbing drinks and dinner with some friends recently, one referenced a guy with whom she had gone out to dinner a few years ago. She thought their meal was simply dinner. Her dining partner thought it was a date. I laughed and said it must have been a fluke. But it wasn’t. It happened to her again. With a different guy.
Doing some margarita-inspired research, I turned to two women seated at the bar next to us and asked, “Hey, have you ever been on a date that you didn’t know was a date?” Their eyes lit up and they immediately shared their own stories of unaware dating disasters.
I posed the same question to my small Facebook audience. Within a few hours, my inbox was flooded with stories. Here are just a few of the responses:
“There was this guy a few years back – I’ll call him Billy because that’s his name. Billy was a friend of a friend who nourished his southern roots with a giant truck, concealed carry permit, and a reputation for being a gentleman. We went dancing several times, often followed by dinner, and he always insisted on paying. You can see how this would be confusing. After the second time, he offhandedly raised the question about whether it was a date, but not in a way that invited a response from me. Not one to tolerate misunderstandings, I finally laid down the ground rules that if he wants to be dating, we can date, but if we’re not dating he needs to stop picking up the check because it’s just confusing. He laughed at my Yankee ways and continued paying.
A ski-trip turned into an overnight stay at his house, which led to no physical contact whatsoever. I thought it weird but assumed he was just being a gentleman. I was reassured of this when he paid for breakfast the next morning. It all came crashing down during “date” five. As we were traipsing through the woods looking for mushrooms, he asked not-so-casually whether a friend was single. It was like pulling a giant needle across a record. That night, I handed my credit card to the waitress with fire in my eyes and never talked to him again.”
“A kid flew back [to Philly] from Seattle (his home state) during summer break just to take me out to dinner. I thought he had come back to visit his friends but no. That was an awkward evening. I genuinely felt terrible for the misunderstanding.”
“I met with a friend from college who I had not seen for five years. I thought we were catching up, but in the middle of dinner she said, ‘I told my roommate that I was coming here with you and she was jealous of our date.’ I then thought it was a date and paid for dinner. After that, I tried to ask her out again, but she couldn’t because she was going on a date. I wished her good luck and I haven’t talked to her since.”
“The worst was finding out that someone actually thought we had been dating for three or four months. He had told all of our mutual friends – except for me! I found out about it on a work trip. He had actually broken up with his real girlfriend because he thought we were dating. Please note we had gone to dinner MAYBE three times over this period of time and each time I paid for my own meal.”
“I asked this girl out for dinner. Dinner went well, had a few drinks afterwards, and then went back to her place and hooked up. When I talked to her a few days later, I said how much I enjoyed our date. Her response: ‘Oh, yeah, that was not a date. But it was nice meeting you.’”
“Hung out with a mutual friend whom I was convinced was gay. He was effeminate. I didn’t get any pings from my ‘he’s checking me out’ radar. I was looking forward to having a new gay BFF. Someone fun! Male energy that I didn’t have to worry about! Someone who I could be totally friendly with without worrying that they would think I wanted to jump them. Happiness!
He shows up, I’m sitting in the theatre. We make chitchat. He seems nervous. There’s a dawning awareness on my behalf that, ‘OH FUCK THIS IS A DATE!’
It’s AWKWARD. AWWWWWWWWWWKWARD. We go out for sushi. It’s still awkward. We make small talk. I can’t wait for the evening to end. Conversation which had previously been fluid was stilted. I’m bored. It’s just…. ugh. I pay – he’s a broke student, I’m a nominally well-paid contractor. That’s also awkward. I take him home. He suggests another date as I drop him off. I don’t remember if there was an awkward attempt at a kiss or if I just did my usual bright and cheery, ‘Well that was fun! See you soon! Give me a hug!’ and bailed. We never went out again.”
“I was at the beach with a group of friends. While walking back to our hotel, I and a male friend got separated from the group. He suggested we get ice cream. I love ice cream. Seemed like a win-win. He casually said, ‘This would be a fun date.’ As we were eating our vanilla swirls, all of a sudden his ice cream-covered lips were moving fast in my direction. Escape! All I could do was quickly recoil and yelled, “What the hell was that?” in front of a crowded ice cream shop. Embarrassed, he scampered away like a little kid and avoided me the rest of the weekend.”
I have a half dozen more of these encounters, including a second account involving ice cream and a botched attempt at a kiss. Perhaps ice cream is an unsung aphrodisiac. I wouldn’t know – I’m lactose intolerant.
The common thread in every single unsuspecting date story was a total lack of clarity. Every situation was based on an assumption of each involved party, and clearly, those assumptions were wrong. Embarrassingly and awkwardly dead wrong. And while I hate to point fingers, only two of 14 stories were submitted by men. Every guy I informally polled was certain he had only been on “real dates.” No gray area about it.
Based on numerous conversations with many unaware daters, here’s my bit of advice:
If you want to ask someone out, be sure to use the word “date.”
If you have no romantic interest in someone, be clear that it is “not a date.”
And if at any point you are unsure, JUST ASK! It’s that simple.
Otherwise, “The Steve Harvey Show” airs weekdays at 2:00pm on NBC. Bring some ice cream.